It might take a lot of trying to find a great Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras that gives you the eyelashes of your dreams, but it can also seem nearly difficult to find one that lasts through allergy season, rain, and tears. Every beauty bag should include a go-to waterproof fave because smudged, runny, or flaky mascara may instantly ruin your makeup look.
So we searched the internet for the most well-liked and well-reviewed Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras, and we tried thirty different brands both at home and in our lab to determine the best of the best. The journey there involved a great deal more than just simulations of sweat and rain and fake tears. Each was assessed for wear, removal, general appearance, and convenience of use. We whittled it down after a lot of actual labor and tears, naming those who were truly exceptional. We also sought the counsel of expert makeup artist Kelli Anne Sewell on how to maximize them.
Best Overall
For a number of reasons, this one is our favorite among all the ones we tried. For a stunning, defined appearance, it firstly volumizes and lengthens the lashes. Everyday wearable natural looks can be achieved with just one coat, but more can be added to heighten the drama. Next, we really like how well the brush separates and combs the lashes to give you a finished fanned-out look. Although this brush has somewhat harsh and spikey bristles, we believe they are the right length and spacing to help the brush properly grab the lashes.
Although we really like the program and the way it looks, its outstanding performance really made it stand out. We had no flaking or smudging during our two-week real-life wear of it, and it held up incredibly well on our lab moisture testing. Finally, compared to most waterproof solutions we have tried, it was far easier to remove. Though it requires a little more work to remove than your typical washable product, a cleansing oil worked well and didn’t need much rubbing.
Essence Lash Princess Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras
We were able to build it up for a thick, false-lash appearance, but we thought the name of this inexpensive option was a little deceptive. The tapered shape of the wand makes it simple to coat the lashes in the inner and outer corners of our eyes. The bristles painted and gripped each lash really nicely, and we were amazed at how beautifully they defined and extended them.
The lashes didn’t become weighed down or their curl ruined because of the formula’s relative lightness. It produced an attractively defined, natural look that works well for daily makeup looks. And it wore beautifully—we tested it in real life and noticed no smearing or flaking, even though we saw some running when we spritzed it directly with water in the lab.
Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara
We think you’ll fall in love with this Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras from Dior just like we did if you prefer to indulge in high-end cosmetics. Its buildable, light-weight product thickens lashes without adding bulk or destroying curls. We really liked that it added clean volume and did a great job of keeping our eyelashes apart as we layered it; it didn’t get clumpy or stick the lashes together. The bristle arrangement of this quite big brush is ideal for creating a fanned-out appearance. And it’s not going anywhere once it’s on. All through the day, it showed no indications of smudging or flaking. Plus points to the company for providing it in cobalt blue, warm brown, and true black.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
We have many favorite Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras from the drugstore, but none better than this Maybelline one. It’s not the best at boosting volume, but other than that, everything about it is excellent. The thin brush, which is slightly tapered to target the inner and outer corner lashes, does an amazing job of grabbing the lashes and uniformly covering them in the lightweight solution.
Each lash was significantly lengthened and defined with a few coatings, all without clumping or making the lashes appear heavy. Whether we wore it in our daily life or conducted spritz testing in the lab, it didn’t flake or smear. It just produced a stunning, fluttery appearance that exquisitely widens the eyes.
L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Mascara
During testing, we also really liked this volumizing drugstore product from L’Oréal. It has a large, curved brush to help hold the lashes in place while applying the solution. Length and thickness are achieved with one application, and dramatic volume is achieved with the second. It’s an adaptable choice that works well for both adding greater drama and everyday definition.
Because of the formula’s high wetness, it should be noted that clumps may occur occasionally; nevertheless, clumping can be lessened by clearing the brush of excess product. As we wore it throughout the day, we observed that it was smudge-resistant, however there was some flaking.
Milk Makeup Rise Lifting + Lengthening Mascara
Although mascara can occasionally cause your lashes to clump together, some brushes—like this one from Milk Makeup—can help lessen that effect. The bristles are spaced out so that the lashes stay apart, and the wand is bent to securely grasp each lash. We enjoyed that it made it easier for us to get long lashes and a complete, fanned-out look during testing. W was able to produce audible volume as well. Because of the silicone covering on the tube, controlling the product is simple and won’t slip through your fingertips. The one thing about the spritz test that we didn’t like was that there was a little bit of smearing. Nevertheless, we didn’t observe flakiness or smudges when we wore it at home.
Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes Waterproof Mascara
This and other very buildable mascara formulas are incredibly versatile and worth having in any cosmetic arsenal. While two or three coats provide significant thickness and drama, one coat of this product gives the lashes faint volume and length. When we layered this mascara, unlike many other buildable and volumizing ones, we didn’t notice any clumping or that it weighted down our lashes. A range of eye shapes and lash kinds were well served by the brush size, which also beautifully parted our lashes. It dried without flaking or smudging at all.
The difficulty of removing this formula is its one drawback. The stunning appearance and remarkable performance make the extra effort required to remove it worthwhile, but be sure you have a solid washing balm or eye makeup remover on hand.
Bobbi Brown No Smudge Waterproof Mascara
I get the impression that this Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras was made to provide length and flawless, understated definition. The brush picks up just enough product so you can apply it precisely and get a finish free of clumps. We thought the brush separated and combed our lashes nicely and was easy to use. It gave length, color, and a little thickness, but since the recipe isn’t highly buildable, volumizing isn’t the best use for it; everyday looks or no makeup are better.
The performance once applied really pleased us. It was among the easiest to remove, not smearing or flaking at all. attempt this choice if you desire the permanence of waterproof mascara but are afraid to attempt one because it can be difficult to remove.
Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara
A makeup look can be badly ruined by clumpy Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras. Try this one if you have trouble finding a waterproof solution that doesn’t clump or cause your lashes to stick together. Its lightweight texture and medium-sized brush comb and separate the lashes without overdrenching them in the product. Just one coat gives length and shape; further coats give a hint of silky fullness. It’s lightweight, and both in our lab testing and at home, we were pleased that it didn’t smear, run, or flake. Only slight volume will be produced by this formula; it is not the most buildable. But if you want length, separation, and a fluffy, defined appearance, we believe this Clinique selection will satisfy you.
Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara
Often, a dry formula or an excess of product on the lashes causes drying mascaras or ones that can be built up for significant volume to flake during the day. This slightly wet formula’s ability to produce dramatic volume without flaking is what we appreciate most about it. The first layer gives the lashes a quite natural appearance, but the second and third layers significantly thicken the lashes. It gives a little bit of length, rapidly adds volume, and helps separate the lashes. After it dried, there were no flakes for the entire day.
Only if you’re prone to smearing should you use this on your upper lashes—one tester did report some smudging under their eyes. Although it required a lot of work to remove, the magnificent appearance it produced and the fact that there was no flaking made the effort worthwhile.
Urban Decay Perversion Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras
Individuals who have straight lashes are aware of the difficulty in maintaining a curl in your eyelashes. If you use a heavy mascara that weighs your lashes down, your lashes may fall out even after using an eyelash curler. For those who require an extremely light mascara, this formula works well because it can be built up and yet feels weightless. Not so much for volume, but perfect for extending and definition; a couple of coats helped make lashes much thicker. We didn’t have any flaking during the testing period, and it gave our lashes a lifted, lengthy appearance. Although we discovered that it was considerably less noticeable when we set the area with powder, we did see some slight smudging around the lower lashes.
What to Look for When Buying a Waterproof Mascara
Formula That Is Smudge-Proof: An excellent Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras shouldn’t run, smudge, or result in racoon eyes. Look for a waterproof solution that, in addition to being waterproof, also makes the promise to be transfer-proof and long-wearing.
Benefits: Waterproof mascaras have several advantages, just like washable mascaras do. There are volumizing choices, formulae for lengthening, etc. To make sure you’re satisfied with both the way your mascara looks and performs, be sure the one you select offers the features you want.
FAQs
What is the best method for applying waterproof mascara?
The same methods that work for non-waterproof mascara can also be used to apply waterproof mascara. Sewell states, “Mascara always starts with a curl, but that’s personal preference.” She explains that in order to coat her lashes evenly, she begins by curling them and then blinks into the mascara wand. After that, she runs the wand into her lashes to apply another layer.
How do you remove waterproof mascara?
The primary drawback of using Maybelline Waterproof Mascaras is that it’s usually harder to take off than mascara made with washable formulas. It is feasible to remove waterproof formulations without damaging your lashes, though. To release mascara, first soak a cotton pad in your preferred micellar water or makeup remover and gently press it on your lashes for thirty seconds. After that, lightly run the cotton pad over your lashes to get rid of most of the formula. After cleansing your face to get rid of any leftover product, use a cotton swab and makeup remover to get rid of any residue left in hard-to-reach places. Try using a cleansing balm if you discover that micellar water or conventional makeup remover aren’t working well for you. The oils in the balm may assist further break down the mascara.
How long does waterproof mascara last?
Just like with ordinary mascara, you should be sure to pick up a fresh tube every three months or so. It’s critical to dispose of old mascara properly to prevent skin sensitivities and eye infections. Over time, makeup can accumulate bacteria, so you want to take every precaution to keep your eyes from becoming contaminated.
